CSP has a zero-tolerance policy for misconduct such as plagiarism, fabrication, and falsification. Cases of misconduct will be investigated and dealt with on a case-by-case basis, with the Editors-in-Chief being responsible for the final decision in all cases.
Types of Plagiarism
Plagiarism is defined by the CSP as the use of information, including textual descriptions, figures/tables and data, from a previously published document without proper citation or reference to the original source. All submitted manuscripts will be checked using plagiarism detection software (Crossref Similarity Check).
Textual Plagiarism
Textual plagiarism is the verbatim copy of a textual description of information that has been published, regardless of citation or reference. This includes text published in an article written by the authors themselves (known as self-plagiarism). To avoid this type of plagiarism, authors are strongly recommended to not use the copy-and-paste method for constructing the text of their manuscript or directly quoting text from other sources.
Duplicate/Redundant Publication
Duplicate/redundant publication plagiarism involves the submission or publication of a study and/or its results and findings more than once. This type of plagiarism includes publishing a study and/or its results and findings in another language or with the information only slightly modified from another publication written by others or by the authors themselves (known as self-plagiarism). Duplicate/redundant publication can result from simultaneous submission of an article; therefore, the journal requires that all authors of submitted manuscripts to provide written assurance that the submitted manuscript is not under consideration nor published elsewhere.
Fabrication
Fabrication is defined as faking raw data, figures, or any supporting files.
Falsification
Falsification, including image manipulation, is manipulating research materials or equipment, or processing/changing/omitting data or results such that the research is not accurately represented in the research record.
Policy on Misconduct
All authors share responsibility for the integrity of the work and are expected to take reasonable steps to ensure that their manuscript complies with accepted standards of research and publication ethics before submission.
If, at any stage after submission and before publication, an author becomes aware of suspected misconduct or credible evidence of a problem in the manuscript, the author should promptly notify the editorial office, provide relevant information, and cooperate with any investigation.
If the journal identifies potential misconduct during the peer-review process, including concerns raised by a reviewer, editor, or member of the editorial staff, the editorial office will suspend peer review while conducting a preliminary assessment. This assessment may include obtaining an independent opinion from another reviewer or editor with relevant expertise and no conflicts of interest. If the available evidence does not provide reasonable grounds to pursue the concern, the assessment and its rationale will be documented, and the peer-review process may resume. If further investigation is warranted, the case will be referred to the Committee on Ethical Publication, comprising designated editorial representatives who have no relevant conflicts of interest.
The corresponding author will be notified in writing of the concerns and invited to coordinate a response from all authors, including relevant explanations and supporting documentation, within a reasonable timeframe specified by the editorial office. The journal reserves the right to contact individual co-authors directly if necessary. If the Committee concludes, after considering the response and available evidence, that the concern is not substantiated, its assessment and reasons will be documented, the authors will be notified, and the peer-review process may resume. If no response is received within the specified timeframe, or the response does not adequately address the concerns, the editorial office may refer the matter to the relevant author's institution(s) and, where appropriate, the relevant regulatory or oversight body, requesting an independent investigation. The journal will consider the findings of any such investigation together with all other available evidence. If misconduct is not substantiated, the peer-review process may resume, provided no other editorial concerns remain. If misconduct is substantiated, the manuscript will be rejected. The individual(s) found to have engaged in or knowingly participated in the misconduct may also be prohibited from submitting manuscripts to any XHP journal for a specified period.
If potential scientific misconduct is reported or identified after an article has been published, the editorial office will refer the case to the Committee on Ethical Publication for investigation and contact the author(s) to request an explanation and relevant supporting documentation. If the concern is not substantiated and no correction is warranted, no change will be made to the published article. If an honest error or other limited problem is identified but the article remains reliable overall, a correction may be published. If the available evidence indicates that the article's findings or conclusions are unreliable, or that another serious breach of publication ethics warrants retraction, the journal may retract the article. An Expression of Concern may be published when there are well-founded concerns about the integrity or reliability of a published article, but the investigation remains ongoing, inconclusive, or cannot be completed in a timely manner. If the authors do not respond within a reasonable timeframe, or their response does not adequately address the concerns, the editorial office may contact the relevant institution(s) and, where appropriate, the relevant regulatory or oversight body to request an independent investigation. The journal will consider the findings of any such investigation together with all available evidence when determining the appropriate editorial action. Authors found to have engaged in or knowingly participated in confirmed misconduct may also be prohibited from submitting manuscripts to any XHP journal for a specified period.
Corrections
CSP is very aware of our responsibility to correct errors in previously published articles. If there is sufficient evidence to prove an error in any published article, corrections must be made as soon as possible, in accordance with the requirements of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Errors include but are not limited to a research claim, the label of a figure or a table that does not alter conclusions, authorship, and so forth. a) Corrections should be made immediately in the electronic version or printed page of the journal. The places that need to be corrected should be clearly indicated, with the correction date. The corrections should be included in the Table of Contents of either an electronic version or a print version of the journal.
b) The corrected version, and the version with errors, should be available for future access upon request from the authors.
c) The prior electronic version should contain a note that clearly indicates the existence of an updated version.
d) If the error is major enough to jeopardize the fundamental results or conclusions of the research, retraction instead of correction will be demanded.
The title of the submission should have the following format: "Corrigendum: Title of original article". It is advised to use the corrigendum Word templates.
Retractions and Expressions of Concern
CSP acts in accordance with the guidelines and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in cases of potential retraction. We also abide by two other key principles, as recommended by COPE: a) Retractions are not about punishing authors.
b) Retraction statements should be public and linked to the original, retracted article.
Although all retractions are dealt with on a case-by-case basis, CSP considers the following examples as sufficient cause for concern and potential retraction:
c) Sufficient evidence that findings are faulty or unreliable, either as a result of misconduct (e.g., data fabrication) or academic error (e.g., miscalculation or experimental error);
d) Findings have previously been published elsewhere without proper permission or justification (i.e., dual publication);
e) Legal or political issues pertaining to the content of the article are identified;
f) Major authorship issues have led to difficulty in determining the legitimate owners of the published work, i.e., proven or strongly suspected cases of ghostwriting or sold (‘gift’) authorship;
When scientific misconduct is alleged, or any concerns are raised about the conduct or integrity of published studies, appropriate procedures will be initiated as detailed by committees such as COPE. An expression of concern may be published pending the outcomes of these procedures. If any major flaw or academic misconduct is confirmed, the publisher reserves the right to retract the paper immediately. Examples of misconduct include but are not limited to data falsification, fabrication, duplication, or plagiarism.
An expression of concern and retraction will be posted, in an electronic or printed version of the Table of Contents, to ensure proper indexing. The title of the original article will be included in the heading. The retracted paper will also be clearly labeled and linked with the retraction letter from both directions.
Readers who would like to draw the editors' attention to published work that might require retraction should contact the authors of the article and write to the journal, making sure to include copies of all correspondence with the authors.
If an article requires retraction, the corresponding author(s) will be required to pay a fee of USD1,000 to cover the costs of retracting the publication.
