Histone acetylation
The entire genome of a eukaryotic organism is condensed into chromatin in the nuclei. The basic unit of chromatin, called the nucleosome, is made up of 147 DNA base pairs wrapped around a core protein octamer called histone.34 These proteins include histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4. Histone H1, located outside of the core octamer, can regulate chromatin fibers in higher-order structure.35 Heterochromatin, which refers to condensed (closed state) chromatin, and euchromatin, which refers to loosely packed (open state) chromatin, are the two major higher-order structures of chromatin. Euchromatin is more accessible to transcription factors and RNA polymerase.35,36 Thus, alteration of chromatin state by DNA methylation or histone modifications impacts gene expression by making certain genes more or less available for transcription.37–39 Histone acetylation, the most studied mechanism of histone modifications, plays a key role in the regulation of gene expression.39,40 In fact, the acetylation of lysine residues (Kac) on histone tails neutralizes the positive charge on the ε-amino group of the lysine residues, leading to the unwinding of tightly coiled heterochromatin, which makes the chromatin be in an accessible state (euchromatin).41 Additionally, the inner pore space of chromatin is increased by histone acetylation, which alters spatial distance and accessibility during interphase, and ensures sufficient space for local initiation and elongation.42,43
HATs and HDACs are the enzymes responsible for histone acetylation and deacetylation, respectively. It has been confirmed that HDACs are expressed by different types of tumors and are involved in carcinogenic events, such as chromosomal translocation-mediated oncogenic protein fusion.44,45
Epigenetic modifiers of histone acetylation in CRC
HDAC inhibitors in CRC
Many preclinical studies and clinical trials have reported the important effect of HDACis as therapeutic agents in different cancers. These epigenetic modifiers can significantly limit tumor growth, restrain aberrantly proliferated vessels,59 induce DNA damage, cell cycle arrest, apoptosis, and autophagy to promote cancer cell death.60 It has been shown that HDACis can inhibit the proliferation of different trans
formed cells in vitro such as lymphoma, leukemia, myeloma, and non-small cell lung carcinoma. They can also stop tumor progression in many solid and hematological tumors. In addition, these HDACis can modulate the immune response and decrease angiogenesis.61
Vorinostat (SAHA)
Vorinostat (N-hydroxy-N′-phenyl-octanediamide) was among the first HDAC inhibitors approved by the FDA in 2006 to treat CTCL (cutaneous T-cell lymphoma) (Fig. 2). Vorinostat inhibits all classes of HDAC enzymes except class III.62 It has been reported that this molecule has a promising effect on gastrointestinal cancers and metastatic CRC in combination with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU). Vorinostat has an ID50 of 10 nM and 20 nM for HDAC1 and HDAC3, respectively. Vorinostat induces cellular apoptosis.63
Valproate (VPA) (an HDACi and DNMTi)
Valproic acid is a drug used for the treatment of seizure disorders, including epilepsy (Fig. 2). It acts as an inhibitor of GABA transaminase, leading to the blocking of voltage-gated sodium channels and T-type calcium channels.64 Recently, it has been reported that this molecule could affect chromatin remodeling. In fact, VPA can alter gene expression through epigenetic marks such as histone acetylation and DNA methylation.64,65 It has been demonstrated that VPA can bind to class I HDAC catalytic sites and inhibit their activity, which leads to histone acetylation, in particular at the lysine 9 residue of histone H3 and the lysine 8 residue of histone H4.66 H4 hyperacetylation activates cell cycle arrest and apoptosis. VPA can also promote proteasomal degradation of HDAC2. In fact, it has been shown that in the HeLa (human cervical carcinoma) cell line, histone H4 hyperacetylation induced by treatment with 3.0 mM VPA for 24 h led to upregulation of more than 1,074 genes, some of which are related to the cell cycle, cell signaling, pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase 4, and ATPase class V, and downregulation of 551 genes including those related to importin β, Fas apoptotic inhibitory molecule, and cyclin B1.67 In another study, in rat neurons treated with VPA, hyperacetylation of H3 and H4 was found only in the promoters of 726 upregulated genes, including genes involved in epileptogenesis.68
Regarding the role of this molecule in CRC, Strey et al.69 reported that VPA exerts an anti-neoplastic effect in many colorectal tumor cell lines (Caco-2, SW-480, CX-1, and WIDR) in vitro by altering cell cycle regulation (cycle proteins cdk1, cdk2, cdk4, cyclin D, cyclin E, p19, p21, and p27 were altered). In fact, this molecule inhibits cell growth and induces cell cycle arrest by the upregulation of H3 and H4 acetylation. Furthermore, tests in vivo in the same study revealed that tumor growth was suppressed by VPA, and apoptosis-related proteins were altered with downregulation of BCL-2 and upregulation of BAX.69,70
Belinostat
Belinostat is a hydroxamic-acid type HDACi used for the treatment of patients with relapsed or refractory PTCL (peripheral T-cell lymphoma) (Fig. 2). Because of its poor metabolic stability, belinostat showed a limited effect in solid tumors, such as colon cancer. To overcome this limitation, a prodrug (Cubisbel: complexation of belinostat to Cu) was synthesized and tested in vitro (in 3 CRC cell lines: Caco-2, SW480, and SW620) and in vivo. The results demonstrated that this prodrug reduced colon cancer cell growth via HDAC inhibition and apoptosis induction. Furthermore, the treatment of colon cancer PDTOs (patient-derived tumor organoids) with Cubisbel led to a significant decrease in cell viability and reduction of stem cell and proliferation markers.71
Resminostat
Resminostat is an orally bioavailable HDAC inhibitor (Fig. 2). It targets different HDACs of classes I and II, including HDACs 1, 3, 6, and 8. It has been shown that Resminostat has an effect on different types of cancer and is promising because of its tolerability, safety, and the possibility to be used in combination with other drugs like sorafenib and docetaxel.72,73 It has been reported that Resminostat can kill cancer cells by affecting the AKT signaling pathway, which can lead to the inhibition of proliferation, migration, and stimulation of apoptosis in CRC cell lines.74 Clinical trials are ongoing for advanced CRC, but no results have been published yet.75
Psammaplin A (PsA)
PsA is a natural molecule isolated from the Psammaplysilla sponge (Fig. 2). This symmetrical bromotyrosine-derived disulfide has various pharmacological activities such as antimicrobial and antitumoral.76 It has been reported that PsA inhibits enzymes like DNA gyrase, farnesyl protein transferase, DNA topoisomerase, and leucine aminopeptidase.76 Additionally, PsA was found to be a potent inhibitor of HDAC, especially Class I HDAC.77 This inhibition is done through the establishment of a coordination link between the zinc ion and the catalytic pocket of HDAC using a sulfhydryl group activated by a reducing agent.77
In CRC, it has been shown that PsA could play a key role. In fact, it inhibits cell proliferation and upregulates expression of the TSG gelsolin in a dose-dependent manner. Also, this molecule induces H3 and H4 acetylation, increases expression of p21, a cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor, and decreases expression of pRb, cyclins, and CDKs, which promote cell cycle arrest.77,78
Parthenolide
Parthenolide (HDAC1 and DNMT1 inhibitor) is a natural bioactive sesquiterpene lactone (Fig. 2). It is found mostly in the flowers and leaves of the feverfew (Tanacetum parthenium) at 0.1–0.2% of its dry weight. It has been shown that Parthenolide inhibits nuclear factor-κB activation by alkylation of Cys38 of the p65 gene and exhibits anti-tumor effects in human malignancies.79 A study reported that this natural bioactive molecule inhibits DNMT1 with an IC50 of 3.5 μM. It acts possibly via alkylation of the proximal thiolate of Cys1226 of the enzyme catalytic domain by its γ-methylene lactone. Furthermore, this molecule downregulates DNMT1 expression. This downregulation may be associated with cell-cycle arrest at SubG1 or the interruption of the binding of a transcription factor Sp1 to the DNMT1 promoter. The same study has shown that Parthenolide leads to the reactivation of the tumor suppressor HIN-1 gene in vitro associated with its promoter hypomethylation.79 Taken together, these results suggest that parthenolide may be an effective anticancer epidrug, in particular against CRC. In fact, it has been reported that parthenolide, as other natural products, inhibits HDAC activity in silico, downregulates HIF-1alpha, and inhibits the NF-κB pathway.80–82
Trichostatin A (TSA)
TSA is a natural product isolated from Streptomyces hygroscopicus (Fig. 2). It is a hydroxamic acid with important pharmacological activities.83 This molecule is also known as an inhibitor of the canonical HDACs class I and II, which makes it one of the most promising epidrug agents against cancer.83 It has been reported that TSA can make cancer cells more sensitive to radiotherapy. In fact, pre-exposure of head and neck cancer cell lines, HN-3 and HN-9, to 200 nM of TSA for 18 h marked them radiosensitive.84
In CRC, Senaei et al.85 showed that Trichostatin can decrease cell proliferation and promote apoptosis. The same author confirmed that this molecule downregulates expression of DNMT1 and HDAC1, and upregulates p21, p27, and p57. Also, in human colon HCT116 cells, it has been shown that TSA, as an HDAC inhibitor, induces cell cycle arrest via induction of p15 (INK4b) and inhibition of cyclin D-dependent kinases.86
Other hydroxamic acid derivatives
Hydroxamate derivatives have been widely explored for their interesting pharmacological activities, particularly against cancer.87 It has been reported by several studies that hydroxamate derivatives could inhibit HDACs. Sixto-López et al.87 showed that hydroxamic acid derivatives inhibited HDAC 1, HDAC 6, and HDAC 8 with antiproliferative activity. Among these molecules, MHY218 has been reported to induce apoptosis, downregulation of NF-κB gene expression, G2/M phase arrest, and increase of p21 (WAF1/CIP1) gene expression level.88 Another aliphatic hydroxamate derivative, WMJ-S-001, induced apoptosis in HCT116 cells, and its action was associated with activation of p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) and AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK), phosphorylation and acetylation of p53, and modulation of proteins such as cyclin D1, p21 (CIP/WAF1), survivin, and BAX. The same study showed that WMJ-S-001 inhibited the growth of subcutaneous xenografts of HCT116 cells in vivo.89
Burkholdacs A
Burkholderia is a pathogenic bacterium that has gained increasing interest because of its genome containing a large number of gene clusters encoding for cryptic small molecules that can interact with proteins (Fig. 2). Among those molecules, Burkholdacs A and Burkholdacs B are the most studied because of their interesting activity as HDAC inhibitors.90 They target HDAC1 and HDAC6 by inhibiting their catalytic activity through reducing disulfide bonds, which leads to the generation of a free thiol group that interacts with the catalytic site of the enzyme. Tested against six CRC cell lines, Burkholdacs A was reported to have more affinity for HDAC1 and a stronger antiproliferative effect than Burkholdacs B.91
Clorgylin
Clorgylin (hydrochloride) inhibits monoamine oxidase A in a potent, selective, and irreversible way (Fig. 2). It has been demonstrated that this molecule could be a good candidate as an epidrug in CRC.92 In fact, clorgylin could restore some silenced TSGs by DNA demethylation of their promoters or by enriching H3K4me2 and H3K4me1 histone marks. Additionally, it has been shown that clorgylin inhibits LSD1 and decreases cancer cell proliferation.92
Nicotinamide
Nicotinamide, a water-soluble form of Vitamin B3, is a precursor of NAD+, which makes this molecule a potent inhibitor of enzymes requiring NAD+ for their activities (Fig. 2)93,94; such as poly-ADP-ribose polymerases, mono-ADP-ribosyltransferases, CD38, and cyclic ADP ribose/NADase. Furthermore, this molecule has been demonstrated to be an inhibitor of the sirtuin family of HDAC NAD-dependent class III enzymes.93,94 Some studies suggest that nicotinamide could play a key role in the prevention and treatment of some cancers such as non-melanoma skin cancer, head and neck cancer, laryngeal cancer, and urinary bladder cancer. In addition, nicotinamide is a safe, well-tolerated, and cost-effective drug.93,94
Gupta et al.95 showed that nicotinamide could be used as an adjuvant treatment in CRC since, when paired with carbogen, it increased the delivery of anticancer drugs to CRC metastases in patients with advanced cancer.
Other molecules
As summarized in Table 3 with references,63,69–71,74,80,81,87,95–107 many other molecules could be used as epigenetic modifiers proposed for the treatment of CRC. These molecules are Panobinostat, Quisinostat, Fimepinostat, Rocilinostat, Pivanex (AN-9), EDO-S101 (Tinostamustine), DC-M01-7, and Anacardic acid.
Table 3Some epigenetic modifiers of histone acetylation in CRC
| Drug | Chemical class | Targeted HDAC/HAT | Status | Selective | Reference |
|---|
| Vorinostat (SAHA) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | FDA (2006) | Yes | 63 |
| Belinostat (PXD101; PX105684) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | FDA (2014) | No | 71 |
| Panobinostat (LBH589) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | FDA and EMA (2015) | No | 96 |
| Resminostat (RAS2410; 4SC-201) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | Phase II | Yes | 74 |
| Quisinostat (JNJ-26481585) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I/II | No | 97 |
| MPT0E028 | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I | No | 98 |
| CUDC 101 | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I | No | 99 |
| Fimepinostat (CUDC-907) | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I | No | 100 |
| Rocilinostat/Ricolinostat (ACY1215) | Benzamide | HDAC-6 | Phase I/II | Yes | 101 |
| Parthenolide | Sesquiterpene lactone | HDAC | | | 80,81 |
| Valproic acid | Fatty acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I/II/III/IV | No | 69,70 |
| AR-42 (OSU-HDAC42) | Fatty acids | HDAC-6 | Phase I | No | 102 |
| Pivanex (AN-9) and AN-7 | Fatty acids | HDAC-6 | Phase II | No | 103 |
| EDO-S101 (Tinostamustine) | Other | HDAC-6 | Phase I/II | No | 104 |
| Nicotinamide | Sirtuins | SIRTs | Phase III | | 95 |
| DC-M01-7 | Sulfonamide | HAT-MOF | | unknown | 105 |
| Anacardic acid | Salicylic acid | P300/CBP | | unknown | 106 |
| MHY218 | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC1, 4, and 6 | | Yes | 87,107 |
| WMJ-S-001 | Hydroxamic acids | HDAC1, 6, and 8 | | Yes | 87,106 |